In this episode, we’re talking about How To Identify and Mitigate Insecure Windows Services. This is a very common issue we see on internal pentests. So much so that day 1 of our internal pentests revolves around evaluating the security and configuration of the endpoint to identify these issues. But this is only the tip of the ice burg.
Introduction
Section Overview: In this episode of the Cyber Threat Perspective podcast, the hosts discuss how to identify and mitigate insecure Windows services. They highlight the common occurrence of this issue in internal pen tests and provide tips for defenders on using a specific tool for identification at scale.
Understanding Insecure Windows Services
- A service is a program that runs in the background on Windows, performing specific tasks without a GUI or interface.
- Services can start and stop automatically and may run as an elevated account, such as the system account.
- Common examples of services include print spooler, fax service, and DHCP client service.
- Services can run as domain accounts, local user accounts (e.g., local admin), or system accounts with elevated privileges.
01:14 Background on Internal Pen Tests
Section Overview: The hosts explain their approach to internal pen tests, which involves assuming a compromised host as a starting point. They emphasize the importance of evaluating endpoints for security configurations and misconfigurations that could aid attackers.
Assumed Breach Style Engagement
- Internal pen tests begin with access to a compromised host rather than deploying a machine on the environment.
- This approach assumes that a user will click on a link or get compromised, allowing access to the internal network.
- Day one of an internal pen test focuses on endpoint evaluation, assessing applications, services, software installations, security configurations, etc., for potential misconfigurations.
02:54 Understanding Services
Section Overview: The hosts delve deeper into what services are and their significance in terms of running in the background without being visible to end users. They also highlight that many services tend to run as an elevated account like “system.”
Definition and Characteristics of Services
- A service is a program that runs in the background without a GUI, performing specific tasks on Windows.
- Services like print spooler are essential but often go unnoticed by end users.
- Many services run as an elevated account, such as the “system” account, which has elevated privileges in the environment.
- Attackers may leverage the system account for lateral movement, code execution, or maintaining persistence due to its high privileges.
03:56 Importance of Mitigating Insecure Services
Section Overview: The hosts emphasize the significance of identifying and mitigating insecure services due to their potential exploitation by attackers. They highlight that services running with elevated privileges can be attractive targets.
Significance of Insecure Services
- Insecure services pose a risk as they can be exploited by attackers to achieve their goals (e.g., obtaining credentials or moving laterally).
- Services running with elevated privileges, such as the system account, are particularly attractive targets for attackers.
- Mitigating insecure services is crucial for maintaining a secure environment and preventing unauthorized access or malicious activities.
05:28 Conclusion
Section Overview: The hosts conclude this section by summarizing the importance of understanding and securing Windows services. They encourage listeners to check out a related blog post for detailed instructions on identifying and mitigating insecure services.
Key Takeaways
- Understanding Windows services is essential for identifying and addressing potential security risks.
- Insecure services running with elevated privileges may be targets for attackers.
- Mitigating insecure services is crucial for maintaining a secure environment and preventing unauthorized access or malicious activities.
Please note that this summary covers only a portion of the transcript provided.
Section Overview: This section discusses the root causes of insecure product installations and how they can lead to security vulnerabilities. The speaker highlights common issues related to improper installation and administrator errors.
Product Installation Issues
- 06:07 The root cause of insecure product installations is often due to the product being installed improperly, either by the installer itself or by misconfigurations during the installation process.
- 06:25 Developers play a crucial role in ensuring secure installations by properly writing and configuring their applications. However, this aspect was often overlooked in the past.
- 06:42 Improper installations can result in security vulnerabilities, as seen in real-world scenarios and even in penetration testing labs.
- 07:55 Insecure services are a common issue caused by software installing itself incorrectly, such as configuring insecure permissions on directories or misconfiguring services.
Administrator Errors
- 09:18 Administrator errors contribute significantly to security issues. Admins may follow vendor instructions without considering potential risks or requirements that could lead to insecure configurations.
- 10:18 Admin error is a prevalent cause of security vulnerabilities, where admins unintentionally introduce issues due to misinterpretation or lack of awareness.
- 11:18 Some admin errors are driven by vendor requirements that cannot be changed without breaking the functionality of the product.
Importance of Secure Product Installations
- 10:58 It is essential for developers to prioritize secure product installations to prevent potential security vulnerabilities.
- 11:18 Admin error should be minimized through proper training and awareness about secure installation practices.
Note: The transcript provided does not specify a language. Therefore, I have assumed it is English based on the content.
12:03 Unquoted Service Paths
Section Overview: This section discusses unquoted service paths and their implications. Unquoted service paths can allow for manipulation of the executable path, potentially leading to the execution of unintended programs.
Explanation of Unquoted Service Paths
- Unquoted service paths refer to service configurations where the path to the executable does not have quotes around it.
- If a path includes spaces and is not wrapped in quotes, Windows will search each directory with spaces in its name for the binary file being run by the service.
- This issue is common with both built-in Windows services and third-party services.
- It can be compared to DLL hijacking, as it takes advantage of the search order in Windows to execute a specific program.
Identifying and Fixing Unquoted Service Paths
- Unquoted service paths are easily identifiable using PowerShell commands or vulnerability scanners like Nessus.
- To fix this issue, simply modify the service configuration so that the path to the executable is wrapped in double quotes.
- Fixing unquoted service paths should have no impact on the functionality of the program.
16:00 Insecure File/Folder Permissions
Section Overview: This section discusses insecure file and folder permissions that can lead to potential security vulnerabilities. Misconfigured permissions on files or folders can allow unauthorized modification or access.
Manifestation of Insecure File/Folder Permissions
- Insecure file/folder permissions occur when a program’s root directory or its associated files have misconfigured permissions.
- This could include allowing everyone or authenticated users to modify or access these files/folders.
Impact and Importance
- Insecure file/folder permissions can lead to various security risks, compromising system integrity and confidentiality.
Identifying and Fixing Insecure File/Folder Permissions
- The issue can be identified by reviewing the permissions of the program’s root directory and associated files.
- To fix this issue, ensure that proper permissions are set, restricting modification or access to authorized users only.
17:51 Conclusion
Section Overview: This section concludes the discussion on unquoted service paths and insecure file/folder permissions. It emphasizes the importance of addressing these vulnerabilities to enhance system security.
Key Takeaways
- Unquoted service paths can allow for unintended program execution and should be fixed by wrapping the path in double quotes.
- Insecure file/folder permissions can lead to unauthorized modification or access and should be addressed by setting proper permissions.
Note: The transcript does not provide further content beyond this point.
18:26 Insecure File and Folder Permissions
Section Overview: This section discusses the issue of insecure file and folder permissions and provides tools to identify and mitigate this vulnerability.
Identifying Insecure File and Folder Permissions
- Use tools like Access Check or icacls to examine the permissions of program files.
- Look at both file permissions and folder permissions in a recursive manner.
- It can be challenging to mitigate this issue without breaking the application or service.
Mitigating Insecure File and Folder Permissions
- Audit the permissions and document the reasons for any necessary access.
- Work with vendors to address permission requirements.
- Remove unnecessary permissions from directories or files to prevent unauthorized modifications.
21:50 Insecure Service Permissions
Section Overview: This section focuses on insecure service permissions, which are different from file and folder permissions. It explains how misconfigured service permissions can lead to security vulnerabilities.
Understanding Service Permissions
- Services have their own set of permissions separate from file and folder permissions.
- Users can be granted various levels of access, including modifying, restarting, stopping, or having full privileges (service all access).
- Misconfigured service permissions can allow low privileged users to modify services, potentially leading to malicious actions.
23:24 Pen Test Example
Section Overview: The speaker shares an example from a recent pen test that involved a combination of insecure file and folder permissions as well as insecure Windows service configurations.
Pen Test Example Description
- During a pen test, the speaker discovered both insecure file and folder permissions as well as insecure Windows service configurations in an environment.
- It is crucial during pen tests to identify the root cause and full scope of vulnerabilities.
- Addressing only one part of a vulnerability may leave other aspects unaddressed, potentially leading to ongoing security risks.
Note: The transcript is already in English, so there is no need to respond in a different language.
24:26 Understanding the Scope and Fixing Permissions
Section Overview: The speaker discusses a scenario where fixing file or folder permissions and changing service permissions can resolve an issue. They emphasize the importance of addressing both aspects to prevent unauthorized modifications.
Fixing File and Folder Permissions
- In cases where there are misconfigured permissions, fixing the file or folder permissions is necessary.
- Changing service permissions to restrict modification by all users is also recommended.
Importance of Due Diligence in Reconnaissance
- Instead of immediately exporting data, thorough reconnaissance and information gathering yield better results.
- Investing time in due diligence during the initial stages pays off throughout the process.
Comprehensive Evaluation for Potential Issues
- When encountering misconfigured permissions, it is crucial to consider other possible issues related to that program or directory.
- Look for unquoted service paths, insecure service permissions, and insecure file and folder permissions as part of a holistic evaluation.
- Exploiting one issue without considering others may lead to incomplete understanding of the overall impact.
26:30 Common Insecure Service Misconfigurations
Section Overview: The speaker highlights three common types of insecure service misconfigurations: unquoted service paths, insecure file and folder permissions, and insecure service permissions. They recommend referring to a blog post for detailed examples with screenshots.
Unquoted Service Paths
- Unquoted service paths are often hidden but can be detected using tools like Nessus or WinPEAS.
- Nessus is effective at finding unquoted service paths but may not report on other types of misconfigurations.
Insecure File and Folder Permissions
- Identifying insecure file and folder permissions requires manual evaluation during vulnerability assessments or penetration tests.
- Tools like WinPEAS or custom PowerShell scripts can assist in identifying these issues.
Insecure Service Permissions
- Similar to insecure file and folder permissions, identifying insecure service permissions requires manual evaluation.
- Tools like WinPEAS or custom PowerShell scripts can assist in identifying these issues.
27:24 Challenges in Evaluating Permissions
Section Overview: The speaker discusses the challenges of evaluating permissions and emphasizes the need for thorough endpoint reviews during vulnerability assessments or penetration tests. They mention tools like PowerSploit and a specific blog post that provides a useful trick for checking systems at scale.
Tricky and Sneaky Permissions
- Evaluating permissions can be challenging as they are not always straightforward.
- Permissions may vary, and it is important to validate and improve the identification of issues.
Additional Tools for Evaluation
- PowerSploit’s Privesc Audit script is an outdated but useful tool for identifying various misconfigurations.
- Other free tools or custom PowerShell scripts can also aid in evaluating permissions.
Trick/Tip for Checking Systems at Scale
- A blog post mentioned in the transcript provides a helpful trick or tip using a specific tool to check multiple systems for these types of issues efficiently.
- The speaker recommends referring to the blog post on offsec.blog titled “Hidden Danger: How to Identify and Mitigate Insecure Windows Services” for more details.
Blog: https://offsec.blog/
Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/@cyberthreatpov
Twitter: https://twitter.com/cyberthreatpov
Work with Us: https://securit360.com